Board Thread:News and Announcements/@comment-5693502-20191005130202/@comment-43971197-20191005134538

Alissa the Wise Wolf wrote: Emergency Alternate Account wrote: Alissa the Wise Wolf wrote: Emergency Alternate Account wrote: Don't judge someone's suitability before even giving them the chance to prove it. Based on the outrage currently happening because of his continued history of problems, it's safe to say pretty much no one wants to give him that chance. They believe the risk too great to humor the idea, and given how things are going, this is going to be a rather clear cut option. I can see that. Doesn't mean they are right.

Why not see how it goes before passing judgement ? Isn't that the reasonable thing to do ?

Not like there is a deadline for this kind of pool. Why freaking out barely a few hours in ? Freaking out barely a few hours in is exactly why its a bad decision. Enough users have had enough bad experiences with Sage to completely denounce him in every facet. He is literally the most hated user on the wiki and for good reason. With that kind of history the option of promotion and a chance are null. I know, that's how it played out so far. Still, the odds of being pleasantly surprised are actually high.

That's why I say we should wait and see.