Category talk:Candidates for speedy deletion

Please use this page to discuss pages that have been labelled for speedy deletion.

It’s a bit unfair to delete if people have issues with breasts, it’s a bit sexist and hypocritical given Reproductive Organ Manipulation Dragon-Fox 7 (talk) 04:21, September 21, 2020 (UTC)

And what about all other powers like Sexual Inducement, Sexuality Manipulation, and so on. Breast are just a part of the human body like arms and legs, it’s seem unfair to delete it because you guys have issues with and changing the rules to to get rid of them it seems a bit manipulative. And plus the FANDOM guidelines does allows us to give exceptions

• If you aren't sure if an image is acceptable or not, there are two questions: Is the nudity in an appropriate context? For example, an image of breasts on the Breast Cancer Wiki would be in an appropriate context.

I Understand the idea of not giving arousal which is why your deleting such gif and pics which is fine but why the whole page can’t there be replacement to better appropriate the page instead Dragon-Fox 7 (talk) 04:38, September 21, 2020 (UTC)

Fundamentally incompatible ? Isn't that a bit of an exaggeration ?

There are many horny-free science fields on the subject, surely a power can do it too.

And after a closer look, this one is already written in a scientific and non-sexual way.

DYBAD (talk) 05:33, September 21, 2020 (UTC)

Reproductive Organ Manipulation is probably going as well, in all candor. The fact that staff haven't gotten to that page yet doesn't make this page okay for the wiki. Sexual Inducement, Sexuality Manipulation, and others are also under active discussion amongst staff. Given that Hypnotic Breasts has been specifically identified as unsuitable for the wiki by Bureaucrats, and that this power is very similar, I identified this as a candidate for speedy deletion. Necrotifice has since added this to Violations, confirming that this page is unsuitable for the wiki. While I sympathize with you on the subject of our society's feelings towards breasts, we have to acknowledge that it is the prevailing opinion and that the rules of this wiki have changed.

Themannamedjeffery420 (talk) 05:47, September 21, 2020 (UTC)

I think it's important to examine each power with clarity, see them for what they effectively are, and not put everything in the same bag.

Reproductive Organ Manipulation is explicitly about toying around with penises and vaginas, so obviously off-limits by its very nature. Similarly, Hypnotic Breast is about turning on observers (that's what the hypnotic part runs on), both the characters and real-life people witnessing it.

Breast in and of themselves however are unrelated to sexuality. They are baby feeders that sometimes happen to look good. Parts of mankind have come to look upon those in a sexual light, but that's really in the eye of the beholder (straight women find them pretty, gay men find them irrelevant, and most breast aren't worth looking at anyway). Should Leather Manipulation be deleted because some people are seriously turned on by a good lashing ? Probably not. Breast Manipulation is pretty much there.

I'm not sure about Sexual Inducement. It is fundamentally about inducing sexual arousal in-universe, but this purely mental and artificially-induced arousal is totally disconnected from any perceptible source, so not arousing at all from an external perspective. The arousal derived from a sexy illusion would reach the audience, but getting turned on out of nowhere just because someone pressed a button in your brain ? Nobody can relate to that.

All it all, this rule should be applied on a case-by-case basis that properly accounts for the specifics of each power, and not just blindly follow mainstream opinions which are blatantly incorrect half of the time.

DYBAD (talk) 07:27, September 21, 2020 (UTC)

DYBAD The voice of reason Dragon-Fox 7 (talk) 07:30, September 21, 2020 (UTC)

For what it's worth, I think DYBAD makes a very good point. Timjer (talk) 07:42, September 21, 2020 (UTC)